Skip to main content
Defence News
  • Home
  • National
  • International
  • Capability
  • Technology
  • People
  • Navy
  • Army
  • Air Force
  1. Home
  2. Letter to the Editor – The Canberra Times

Letter to the Editor – The Canberra Times

22 June 2011

I refer to a letter appearing in The Canberra Times on 22 June from Mr A Wilkinson regarding Australia’s purchase of the new fifth generation Joint Strike Fighter aircraft.

In his letter Mr Wilkinson compares the Joint Strike Fighter with the now-retired F-111 in terms of operational capability.

Having flown some 2,000 hours on F-111s, and having served as the Commanding Officer of an F-111 squadron and Officer Commanding 82 Wing, I agree that the F-111 was a formidable long-range strike platform in its time.  It served Australia well for over 30 years in meeting Australia’s regional strategic needs, but it was an ageing aircraft – in the vintage category for a front-line combat aircraft.  The F-111 would have been vulnerable in a future air combat environment dominated by fourth and fifth generation aircraft and modern air defence systems.

In this modern era of advanced air combat technology and multi-networked platforms, Australia’s requirement is for a cutting edge fifth generation aircraft that provides both fighter and strike roles. The F-111’s ability to penetrate modern air defence systems without an escort would be constrained, effectively limiting its range to that of its escort.  While the F-35 will not have the range of the F-111, nor do other contemporary aircraft.  The F-35’s range will be extended by using stand-off weapons and in-flight refuelling.

In terms of the ability to conduct strike missions, the F-111 relied on flying fast and low to survive and reach the target.  New generation threats have required a new approach – utilising stealth and advanced long range sensors and weapons.  The stealthy, fifth generation F-35 has been designed to deal with the future threat environment – threats from both the ground and from the air.  The acquisition of 24 Super Hornets enabled the F-111’s retirement in 2010 and provided an appropriate and low risk bridging capability until the more capable F-35 arrives.

As Mr Wilkinson rightly points out, specific F-35 performance details are highly classified and tightly controlled to protect U.S. technology and avoid compromising a key defence capability.  This unfortunately often leads to flawed analysis of F-35 capabilities due to incorrect assumptions, simplistic modelling, lack of operational analysis – basically, a lack of access to sensitive performance information.  As a partner on the F-35 Program since 2002, the Government’s commitment to acquiring the F-35 is based on very detailed and ongoing analysis.  The F-35 is the only multi-role fifth generation aircraft that meets our needs.

Air Vice-Marshal K. Osley
Program Manager New Air Combat Capability

Media contacts

Issued by Ministerial and Executive Coordination and Communication,
Department of Defence, 
Canberra, ACT
Phone: 02 6127 1999 Fax: 02 6265 6946 

Other On the record content

Statement by Greg Moriarty, Secretary of the Department of Defence – Global Switch Ultimo

Statement from Greg Moriarty, Secretary of the Department of Defence

Submarine escape, rescue and abandonment system contract termination

International military training resuming in 2021

Statement from Chief of Navy - Submarine safety

Subscribe to our RSS Feed

  • Media releases
  • Stories
  • Transcripts
  • On-the-record list

© Copyright / Defence News

All rights reserved

Defending Australia and its National Interests Small shape of Australia with tagline
  • Contact us
  • Copyright
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy
  • Feedback